Toolbar

Printer Friendly Email RSS Feed Bookmark
Home Product Reviews Recipes Breads Pizza Crusts
Mitch's Basic Pizza Dough
PDF Send Print

Rate it!

Votes (166) | Comments (13)
By Mitch Mandell
Photo: Mitch Mandell
Posted July 23rd, 2007
FabulousFoods.com Recommends: American Pie: My Search for the Perfect Pizza, by Peter Reinhart, (2003, Ten Speed Press)
American Pie: My Search for the Perfect Pizza
Buy Now
Servings: 4
Author Notes: Mitch Mandell (co creator of this site) claims to make the world's best pizza dough. By his own admission, any time you bring the word "world" into a description (Disney World, Camping World, Burger World), it must be good.

After a lot of coaxing, Cheri got Mitch to share his pizza dough recipe with the Fabulous Foodies who visit this site. Since this recipe is his baby, let's let him take it from here.

Mitch's Pizza Dough Notes: I know it's called "Basic Pizza Dough", but the only thing basic about it is how to make it. Most people say "this is the best crust I've ever had."

Many times with grocery store or take out pizza the edge of the crustis left on the plate. Well, that won't happen with this crust. Your family and friends are sure to eat the whole thing.

When all your friends ask you for the recipe, you can come to the top of this page and email it them at the click of a button (we figured this would save you a lot of time copying or printing it out. ;)

This dough is easiest to make in a food processor or bread maker. You can, however, make it by hand (there's just a lot of mixing and kneading that way). Feel free to add ingredients to the dough to make it more interesting. I've often added minced garlic or rosemary or basil. I've even added chopped peanuts for the Thai Style Pizza (recipe link below). It's your pizza, be creative.

Click here for detailed pizza making and dough rolling instructions.

Ingredients: 3 1/2 cups flour
1 cup warm water
2 tablespoons yeast
2 tablespoons honey
1/4 cup olive oil
1/2 teaspoon salt
Instructions: Three choices in mixing your dough: Mixing Dough in a Food Processor:
Some Food Processors come with a dough blade. If you have it use it. If you don't, just use the standard cutting blade. My dough blade broke from over use (some would call it pizza abuse, but that's another story) and the regular blade works fine. Pour in warm water. The water should be about 85 to 115° F. Test it with your hand. It should feel very warm, but comfortable. Add the honey and salt. Mix on low for about 20 seconds. Add the yeast and mix on low for another 5 seconds. Add 1 cup of flour, mix on low for 10 seconds. Add the olive oil and mix until blended (about 15 or 20 seconds more). Add the rest of the flour (and any other additions) and mix on high for about a minute or two. The dough should turn into a ball and roll around the processor. If the dough does not ball up because it's too dry, add water one tablespoon at a time until it does. If your mixture is more like a batter, add flour one tablespoon at a time. Adding water or flour as needed to get the right consistency will assure you always get a perfect dough. Just remember to do it in small amounts.

Once the dough is balled up, place the ball on a floured board and knead for about a minute. This builds the gluten which helps the dough to rise and become fluffy when cooked. Place the dough in a plastic grocery bag or a covered bowl and store in a warm, dry area to rise.

making pizza doughsAfter about 45 minutes the dough should have about doubled in size. Show it who's the boss and punch it down. That's right, give it a good smack so it deflates. Let it rise for another hour to an hour and a half. The dough is now ready to be rolled out. You can punch the dough down one more time if you want and wait another hour or two before rolling out. The choice is yours.

You're now ready for the next step: Rolling out the dough.

This dough can also be made in advance and refrigerated for a day or so, or even frozen. Be sure to let the dough come to room temperature before using.

To Mix Dough in a Bread Machine:
Throw all the ingredients in, set to dough only setting, push start and walk away. That's it! No work, no hassle. If you don't work for something is it really worth having? In this case, you bet!

Once the machine "beeps" and your dough is ready, it's time to go on to the next step - Rolling Out The Dough.

This dough can also be made in advance and refrigerated for a day or so, or even frozen. Be sure to let the dough come to room temperature before using.

To Mix Dough by Hand:
Pour warm water into a bowl. The water should be about 85 to 115° F. Test it with your hand. It should feel very warm, but comfortable. Add the honey and salt. Mix by and hand (or any other method) until well blended. Add the yeast and mix some more. Let this mixture sit for about 5 minutes. Add 1 cup of flour and the olive oil and mix until well blended. Add the rest of the flour (and any other additions) and mix well. The dough should turn into a ball. If the dough does not ball up because it's too dry, add water one tablespoon at a time until it does. If your mixture is more like a batter, add flour one tablespoon at a time. Adding water or flour as needed to get the right consistency will assure you always get a perfect dough. Just remember to do it in small amounts.

pizza dough recipesOnce the dough is balled up, place the ball on a floured board and knead for about a minute. This builds the gluten which helps the dough to rise and become fluffy when cooked. Place the dough in a plastic grocery bag or a covered bowl and store in a warm, dry area to rise.

After about 45 minutes the dough should have about doubled in size. Show it who's boss and punch it down. That's right, give it a good smack so it deflates. Let it rise for another hour to an hour and a half. The dough is now ready to be rolled out. You can punch the dough down one more time if you want and wait another hour or two before rolling out. The choice is yours.

You're now ready for the next step: Rolling out the dough.

This dough can also be made in advance and refrigerated for a day or so, or even frozen. Be sure to let it come to room temperature before using.


 

Comments
Yeast?
Written by: Mitch Mandell
21 November 2008
Fred, that is a common question.  2 Tablespoons of yeast can taste a bit like a brewery, but a lot of people like that yeasty flavor.  You can adjust your yeast level anywhere form 2 teaspoons on up, depending on the flavor you want.
Yeast?
Written by: Fred
19 November 2008
Is it necessary to add so much yeast? I have made this dough twice, using different flours and both times the yeast taste is very noticeable. Thanks.
Question on Flour
Written by: Mitch Mandell
17 November 2008
Good question and one we get a lot.  It's totally fine to use bread flour with this recipe.  In fact, that's the flour I used to use exclusively.  It will make your crust a little more airy and puffy, which is great if you like it that way.   We like to mix and match flours here for a little variety.  Sometime we'll use semolina for a more traditional dough or wheat flour for something a little different.  The dough is not rocket science and if you follow the proportions it's fun to experiment with different flours for different tastes and textures.
question on the flour
Written by: Mirapu
16 November 2008
first of all,sorry if this is a silly question. just wondering if you can use bread flour w/this or if you should not or should use it and why? thanks so much!
Best pizza dough recipe I've tried
Written by: Josh
11 November 2008
I have tried many recipes and they ranged from mediocre to horrible. Tonight I made the best pizza to date. The crust rivaled almost all restaurants I have ever tried. If I had a wood fired oven, I think it might would come out on top of the heap.

The proportion of ingredients is very different than what I have tried before, so I was doubtful that it would turn out well. I guess this is the right balance of ingredients. For one, you called for more than twice the yeast than I usually use. And second, you call for quite a bit of honey (I had to sub out for agave nectar since I'm vegan). I guess it makes sense that if I kept trying nearly identical recipes, then the dough would never turn out any better.

Well, my search for dough recipes had ended on this page. Thanks, Mitch!
Mix by hand
Written by: Cheri Sicard
30 October 2008
Thanks for pointing this out in the instructions.  Mix by hand is just that, mixing by hand.  I have fixed the instructions to reflect this.  When you do get the hang of making the dough, you'll see just how easy it is and wonder why yo didn't try it sooner.
About mixing by hand
Written by: Dan Scott
30 October 2008
I'm a novice when it comes to the kitchen. In the "mix by hand" part it says to mix on low. Does that mean to use an electric mixer? I usually prefer to avoid electric tools. How can that be explained to someone like me who is (a little bit) clueless?
Erica Marcus issues public mea culpa
Written by: Cheri Sicard
31 July 2008
On 7-31-08 Mitch received this email from food writer Erica Marcus regarding her column unfairly trashing this recipe and website:  
Mitch,

at the end of my column today, I issued a "mea pizza culpa":
Please convey this to Cheri as well. Again, apologies.
All best,
Erica
Honestly THE best pizza dough ever
Written by: Anna Conway
30 July 2008
I LOVE this pizza dough. I give this one out to everyone I know (though I only use 1tbps of yeast....) I make this dough every few weeks - tried, tested and fabulous!!!
I registered just to post a comment!
Written by: Troy
30 July 2008
I began a search today for pizza dough and came across this one (it was one of the first Google hits).  I was interested and decided to use this recipe.  Then I began to read the comments and due to the response I decided to read the article by Erica everyone was talking about.After reading the article, I decided to try the recipe the article referenced as an authenticated recipe (or whatever word you want to use).  So I made both!  I did not have an oven that would go to 800 degrees Fahrenheit, so I can't really say that I followed the Peter Reinhart recipe exactly; but I did follow both as closely as possible and cooked all the pizzas in a 500 degree oven (on a pizza stone on the bottom rack of the oven).  The oven was well pre-heated with the stone and only one pizza was cooked at a time.The entire family was involved and we called the "Mitch" dough the "sweet" one because of the honey in it.  I guessed that simply calling it sweet would turn my wife off; however, we all agreed (my wife included) that Mitch's recipe was not only better, but also easier to work with.  We decided that the Peter dough was too dry, not crispy, just dry (again, an 800 degree oven probably would have changed that, but at 500 degrees, the toppings will burn before the crust is crispy).I cooked the pizzas for about 6 minutes on 500 and the toppings came out perfect.  I used ½ cup of sauce based on a recipe I found here (http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Exquisite-Pizza-Sauce/Detail.aspx) which I did add some red wine to and modified to my family’s taste.  This sauce is AWESOME!!  I don’t care who came up with it, just use it!While I have to admit that I do GENERALLY agree with the Erica article, I also believe that there are a lot of talented cooks/chefs out there that have some great recipes!  The most obvious comparison that comes to my mind is when it comes to smoked meats or Cajon cooking.  Who wants to get a smoked brisket recipe from a chef trained in France?  If I want some smoked ribs, brisket or pork butt, I am going to look to a red neck for advice.  Also, if I want some killer gumbo or jambalaya (even though Emril has some awesome Cajon recipes) I want to get mine from a "coon ass".I believe that the best recipe comes from an individual's research and adaptation to his or her own tastes.THE BOTTOM LINE:  This is a great pizza dough recipe!  I have tried it and recommend it!

 

Not all Internet journalists are created equal
Written by: Heather
29 July 2008

Mitch,

Here's my .02 on the editorial by Erica Marcus...it probably won't be printed so I'll share a copy with you.  Thank you for the great dough recipe!

Heather 

 

In the 7/23/2008 article “Not all Internet recipes are created equal” by Erica Marcus, what kind of questions are "Do you know how to cook?" or even "Do you exist?" to someone seeking a recipe.  #1  If one did not exist, recipe seeking would not be happening.  #2  Most people are aware of their capabilities in the kitchen and if they can’t cook, then nuke-able MREs are the way to go. 


Our family selected Mandell's pizza dough recipe for simplicity and the ability to cook the pizza that evening, or to refrigerate or freeze dough for later.  We decided to view additional recipes and make yeast, sugar and flour modifications to suit our tastes. What a jackpot Mandell's recipe was as we only altered by substituting whole wheat flour and wheat germ for part of the grains! 

We find most of our recipes online and have had great success broadening our culinary horizons!  How reliable is a food journalist that has not been tasted the food item ?  Not all journalists are created equal.

A follow up to Erica Marcus' column
Written by: Cheri Sicard
25 July 2008
A food blogger in the UK was particularly incensed at the spirit of Erika Marcus's ctritical artcile. Even though he credited the recipe to me instead of my business partner Mitch Mandell, we nonetheless appreciate the support. Read Erica Marcus' original offending article at this link Read UK blogger Mr. Qwerty's commentary athttp://thehellitis.blogspot.com/2008/07/not-all-internet-recipes-are-created.html
Pizza Dough Recipe Creates Controversy
Written by: Cheri Sicard
25 July 2008

Dear Erica,

 

How reliable is a critique of a recipe by a writer that has never tried it?  

 

How reliable is a writer that does not research her stories?  

 

Had you delved deeper into the story as a "real" journalist does you would have found out that I have worked with chefs and pizza experts to create my pizza recipe.  During my days in advertising I worked with restaurants and pizza restauranteurs and I learned what it takes to make a great dough.  I have made this dough hundreds of times and modified it numerous times before posting.  Now If I was making a gourmet, 5 star meal then you may have something as I never claim to be a chef.  But making peasant food like pizza is not brain surgery.  

 

If you don't personally like sweet, yeasty dough that's fine. Many people do. There are other pizza dough recipes at FabulousFoods.com that use less honey and yeast for those that want a more traditional dough.  But, try recipes and talk to the creator before critiquing it.  Would Anthony Bourdain or Ruth Reichl write or tape a review before eating at a restaurant or trying a recipe? I don't think so.  

 

You may want to try a little research before you trash someone and something you have never tried.  That's Journalism 101.  I know, I took Journalism 101. 

 

Here's what a few have written about my dough that have actually made it. (I have many, many more e-mails as almost everyday I get praise  by people that have actually made the dough) 

--------

Just wanted to say thank you for the great pizza dough recipe on your web site. As an Italian American living in beautiful San Miguel de Allende Mexico I yearned for some great pizza (Domino's is our best option). Now I can make my own which remind me of my dad's great Napolitano pizza's. Thanks again! Marco Giancola

 

-------

I googled your recipe and was going to have my daughter and her neighborhood kids make pizzas at a BQ we were having.  The kids loved it and the adults were suprised at how great the pizzas came out.   We were all fighting and begging the kids to give us another bite.  Thank you for sharing.  Heidi Mylo --------Just dropping a note of thanks for the recipe here: http://www.fabulousfoods.com/recipes/breads/yeast/pizzadough.htmlI've made 3 pizzas so far with it.  I reverse-engineered my favorite pizza from a local restaurant (spicy white sauce, red onion, pepperoninis) and it was the best pizza I ever ate.  Even my wife was suitable impressed. Paul F. Bramscher --------we did a quick search last night for a pizza dough recipe -- and i'll have to say it might be the world's best.....pretty darn good. Patti --------
Erica, I could go on and on, but the people have spoken. Right now, your opinion has NO credibility as you've NEVER eaten the food that you write about.  
 You can please some of the people some of the time but you can't please someone who's never tasted your cooking. ----------Mitch Mandell Publisherwww.FabulousFoods.comwww.FabulousTravel.com
www.FabulousLiving.com

You must be a registered member to leave a comment. So why not sign up now?

 

Sign up for Cheri's FabulousFoods Newsletter/Blog

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Recently Added
Banner

FabulousLiving.comFabulousFoods.comFabulousTravel.comSheKnows